terclim by ICS banner
IVES 9 IVES Conference Series 9 GiESCO 9 Uncovering the effectiveness of vineyard techniques used to delay ripening through meta-analysis

Uncovering the effectiveness of vineyard techniques used to delay ripening through meta-analysis


Context and purpose of the study – One of the most concerning trends associated with increasing heat and water stress is advanced ripening of grapes, which leads to harvesting fruit at higher sugar concentrations but lacking optimal phenolic (i.e. color and mouthfeel) and aromatic maturity. Mitigation techniques for this phenomenon have been studied for many years and practices to delay sugar accumulation have been identified, including antitranspirants, delayed pruning and late-source-limitation techniques. Evaluation of the efficacy of these vineyard practices has occurred across a wide range of environments, vintages, varieties and growing conditions. To assess the broader efficacy of these three vineyard practices, which are easy-to-implement and cost-effective, a meta-analytic approach was adopted using data retrieved from 43 original studies.

Material and methods – A systematic review of published studies on techniques to delay ripening was conducted searching several databases (Web of Science, Pub Med and Google Scholar). This initial database was further screened, and inclusion/exclusion criteria were applied, keeping only studies that met the prerequisites for meta-analysis. Effect size values were calculated as the difference between total soluble solids (TSS) in the control and treated groups to numerically express advanced ripening (negative effect size), delayed ripening (positive effect size) as well as the intensity of the delay. Standard errors were calculated for effect size values and used as a proxy for study accuracy. Forest plots were employed to calculate the average effect of each treatment and associated confidence intervals. Meta-regression models were built to identify relationships between effect size values and important viticultural parameters, including environmental and growing conditions.

Results – Data curation returned 242 effect size values for three practices proposed to delay ripening: antitranspirants (n = 102), delayed pruning (n = 45) and late source limitation (n = 56). Average effects for all treatments were significant, confirming the stability of treatment effects for the vineyard practices investigated. Factors impacting the effectiveness of the treatments were identified through meta-regression. For antitranspirants, the intensity of the delay was dependent on the active compound utilized as well as the timing of spraying. Late pruning was more effective when applied at later stages of apical bud development, and the ability to delay ripening adopting this approach was dependent on vine yield. Similarly, yield was an important parameter impacting the efficacy of late source limitation practices, which also resulted in larger delays when grapes were harvested at higher sugar concentrations. This study shows the usefulness of meta-analysis to demonstrate broader applicability of specific studies through a comprehensive, quantitative and fully data-driven analysis.


Publication date: July 6, 2023

Issue: GiESCO 2023

Type: Article


Pietro PREVITALI1, 2, Filippo GIORGINI3, Randall MULLEN4, Nick DOKOOZLIAN2, 5, Kerry WILKINSON1, 2, Christopher FORD1, 2

1The University of Adelaide, Department of Wine Science, PMB1 Glen Osmond, SA, 5064, Australia
2Australian Research Council Training Centre for Innovative Wine Production, PMB1 Glen Osmond, SA, 5064, Australia
3Department of Economy, Management and Statistics, University of Milano-Bicocca, I-20125 Milano, Italy
4E. & J. Gallo Winery, Research and Development Statistics, 600 Yosemite Boulevard, Modesto, CA 93534
5E. & J. Gallo Winery, Winegrowing Research, 600 Yosemite Boulevard, Modesto, CA93534

Contact the author*


antitranspirants, delayed ripening, late pruning, meta-analysis, source limitation, sugar accumulation


GiESCO | GIESCO 2023 | IVES Conference Series


Related articles…


Climate change has brought several impacts that are becoming increasingly intense during the last few years and put at risk the quality of the berries or even the plant’s sustainability. Such extreme climatic events impact the composition of the wine while modulating its quality and the consumer preferences (Tempère et al., 2019). The three most important changes that take place in the must are: 1) decrease acidity, 2) increase of the concentration of sugar, hence increase of alcohol in the wine, and 3) modification
of the sensory balance and the development for example of cooked fruit aromas.


In Italy, in the past two decades, the rate of temperature increases (0.0369 °C per year) was slightly higher compared to the world average (0.0313 °C per year). It has also been indicated that the number and intensity of heat waves have increased considerably in the last decades. (IEA, 2022). Viticultural zones can be classified with climatic indexes. Huglin’s index (HI) considers the temperature in a definite area and has been considered as reliable to evaluate the thermal suitability for winegrape production (Zhang et al., 2023).

A synthesis approach on the impact of elevated CO2 on berry physiology and yield of Vitis vinifera

Besides the increase in global mean temperature the second main challenge of a changing climate is the increase in atmospheric carbon dioxide (CO2) in relation to physiology and yield performance of grapevines. The benefits of increasing CO2 levels under greenhouse environment or open field studies have been well investigated for various annual crops. Research under free carbon dioxide enrichment on field-grown perennial plants such as grapevines is limited to a few studies. Further, chamber and greenhouse experiments have been conducted mostly on potted vines under eCO2 conditions.

Microbial ecosystems in wineries – molecular interactions between species and modelling of population dynamics

Microbial ecosystems are primary drivers of viticultural, oenological and other cellar-related processes
such as wastewater treatment. Metagenomic datasets have broadly mapped the vast microbial species
diversity of many of the relevant ecological niches within the broader wine environment, from vineyard
soils to plants and grapes to fermentation. The data highlight that species identities and diversity
significantly impact agronomic performance of vineyards as well as wine quality, but the complexity
of these systems and of microbial growth dynamics has defeated attempts to offer actionable
tools to guide or predict specific outcomes of ecosystem-based interventions.

Searching for the sweet spot: a focus on wine dealcoholization

It is well known that the vinification of grapes at full maturation can produce rich, full-bodied wines,
with intense and complex flavour profiles. However, the juice obtained from such grapes may have very
high sugar concentration, resulting in wines with an excessive concentration of ethanol. In addition, the decoupling between technological maturity and phenolic/aromatic one due to global warming, exacerbates this problem in some wine-growing regions. In parallel with the increase of the mean alcohol content of wines on the market, also the demand for reduced alcohol beverages has increased in recent years, mainly as a result of health and social concerns about the risks related to the consumption of alcohol.