Macrowine 2021
IVES 9 IVES Conference Series 9 Evaluation of Polarized Projective Mapping as a possible tool for attributing South African Chenin blanc dry wine styles

Evaluation of Polarized Projective Mapping as a possible tool for attributing South African Chenin blanc dry wine styles

Abstract

Multiple Factor Analysis (MFA) According to the Chenin blanc Association of South Africa, there are three recognized dry wine styles, Fresh and Fruity (FF), Rich and Ripe Unwooded (RRU), and Rich and Ripe Wooded (RRW), classically attributed with the help of sensory evaluation. One of the “rapid methods” has drawn our attention for the purpose of simplifying and making style attribution for large sample sets, evaluated during different sessions, more robust. Polarized Projective Mapping (PPM) is a hybrid of Projective Mapping (PM) and Polarised Sensory Positioning (PSP). It is a reference-based method in which poles (references) are used for the evaluation of similarities and dissimilarities between samples. Panelists are presented with “free-moving” products to arrange around the poles, according to similarities and dissimilarities, to create a 2D product map. Additionally, the judges give a description of the samples, generating a short list of attributes. Our approach to testing this method was to first establish the poles using PM, then test the model using PPM with samples that were either known (used in the PM session and that contributed to the choice of poles) or unknown. The sample set consisted of 18 commercial Chenin blanc wines, vintages 2013 and 2014, from the three representative styles, chosen according to the tasting notes description. Four PPM experiments were performed. The poles were kept constant among the PPM experiments, while different combinations of “free-moving” wines were evaluated to test the consistency of product groupings. In all tasks sensory descriptors were generated. For each session 15 judges were recruited. Each judge repeated the exercise after a 15 minute break. For PM the sample set consisted of 12 samples (9 wines, 3 of them duplicates). For PPM, the sample sets also had 12 samples, with one of the poles and one other sample duplicated. The PPM sessions were organized as follows: PPM1 same samples as PM, PPM2 and PPM3 half known and half unknown samples, and PPM4 only unknown samples. The data generated was evaluated statistically by means of multiple factor analysis (MFA). Multiple factor analysis (MFA) on the individual tasks showed in the PM and all four PPM tasks, the RRW group separated most clearly from other wines and blind duplicates of this style grouped well together. The FF and RRU styles grouped less consistently from one task to another and blind duplicates were not grouped as closely to one another. MFA results comparing all four PPM experiments showed good repeatability in grouping of wines among the separate sessions, especially for wooded wines. New rapid methods provide significant cost benefits for the wine industry and researchers. PPM may be a useful tool for researchers to apply in the analysis of large sample sets of wines.

Publication date: May 17, 2024

Issue: Macrowine 2016

Type: Poster

Authors

Astrid Buica*, Christine Wilson, Jeanne Brand

*Stellenbosch University

Contact the author

Tags

IVES Conference Series | Macrowine | Macrowine 2016

Citation

Related articles…

Sensory impacts of the obturator used for the Chasselas: study over the time

Many parameters affect the organoleptic characteristics of wine: internal parameters like the chemical composition or polyphenol content and external as for example storage conditions or the type of obturator. The aim of this study was to characterize sensorally the impacts of several type of obturator on a white wine: Chasselas. To determine the organoleptic characteristics of this wine, a quantitative descriptive analysis could be used. But rapid sensory methods were preferred in this project. Indeed these methods are an appropriate alternative to conventional descriptive methods for quickly assessing sensory product discrimination.

Maturation of Agiorgitiko (Vitis vinifera) red wine on its wine lees: Impact on its phenolic composition

Maturation of wine on lees (often referred as sur lie) is a common practice applied by many winemakers around the world. In the past this method was applied mainly on white and/or sparkling wine production but recently also to red wine production. In our experiment, we matured red wine on wine lees of two origins: a) Light wine lees, collected after the completion of the alcoholic fermentation, b) Heavy lees, collected after the completion of the malolactic fermentation. The lees were free of off-odors and were added in the red wine in percentage 3% and 8%, simulating common winemaking addition. The maturation lasted in total six months and samples were collected for analysis after one, three and six months. During storage the lees were stirred.

South Africa’s top 10 Sauvignon blanc wines. How do the chemical and sensory profiles compare?

FNB Top 10 Sauvignon Blanc competition, presented by the Sauvignon Blanc Interest Group of South Africa and sponsored by First National Bank, is the country’s foremost platform for producers of this cultivar to showcase and benchmark their wines. Wines entered in the competition originated from all over the winegrowing regions of the country and the winning wines showed good representation of quality South African Sauvignon blanc wines. The ten selected wines were subjected to various chemical analyses including volatile thiol and methoxypyrazine determination, while the sensory profile of each wine was determined using projective mapping.

Mean polymerization degree of proanthocyanidins of grape seeds, skins and wines from Agiorgitiko (cv. Vitis vinifera): Differences among vintages

Grape phenolic compounds are very important constituents of red wine because, in addition to their antioxidant properties, they contribute to color, astringency and bitterness, oxidation reactions, interactions with proteins and ageing behavior of wines. The aim of our study was to assess the structural characteristics of grape and wine proanthocyanidins of Agiorgitiko variety and to evaluate the influence of the vintage year. Twelve vineyard locations were designated in the Nemea wine region. For three consecutive years (2012-2014), the grapes were harvested at technological maturity and the method of phloroglucinolysis was employed to determine the mean degree of polymerization (mDP) and subunit composition of the samples.

Sensory definition of green aroma concept in red French wines. Evidence for the contribution of novel volatile markers

The aromatic complexity of a wine results from the perception of the association of volatile molecules and each aroma can be categorized into different families. The “green” aromas family in red wines has retained our attention by its close link with the fruity perception. In that study, the “green” olfactory concept of red wines was considered through a strategy combining both sensory analysis and hyphenated chromatographic techniques including HPLC and MDGC (Multidimensional Gas Chromatography). The aromatic space of this concept was specified by lexical generation through a free association task on 22 selected wines by a panel of wine experts. Then, 70 French red wines were scored on the basis of the intensity of their “green” and “fruity” attributes.