First application of an original methodology created to overcome conflicts between stakeholders in an important wine-growing territory: methodology, results, and perspectives in the application of sustainability EME4.1C

Abstract

Context and purpose of the study. Considering the previous research and activities, also, on Sustainability EME4.1C which, as widely known, considers in a harmonious chain all the factors material, immaterial, moral and spiritual related to all aspects environmental, economic, social, existential, relational, ethical, technical and “MetaEthic” indexed 4.1C and 5.1C of the Great Chain Meta Ethic 4.1C of the EcoMetaEthic Algorithm4.1C or AlgorMetaEthical4.1C of the Conegliano Campus 5.1C exposed in Italy and abroad (Cargnello G, 1991÷2024; Carbonneau A. and Cargnello G, 2012÷2023; Cargnello G. and Zironi R., 2015, 2017, Boatto V., Cargnello G., Galletto L., Scaggiante S., Zironi R., Bosso A., Barisan L., Teo G., Battistella A., Dal Bianco A., 2017; Boatto V., Cargnello G., Galletto L., Scaggiante S., Bolzanella C., Zironi R., Velasco R., Bosso A., Barisan L., Teo G., 2018; Cargnello G., Ferretti C. e Perini L. 2021; Carbonneau A., Cargnello G., Torregrosa L., Ojeda H., Teo G. 2021; Cargnello G., Forest don A. e Carbonneau A. 2021; Carbonneau A. 2023; Cargnello G. e Forest don A., 2024), those exposed in the works proposed to this GiESCO 2025 (Cargnello G,, Giacomini C., Passador F., Sartor C., Teo G.; Cargnello and Coll.) and, in particular, those conducted in Lazio since 2011, (Giovanni Cargnello, Alain Carbonneau, Roberto Zironi), who, while going further, valorize the encyclicals Laudato Si and Fratelli tutti. In the territory of Prosecco DOCG, Prosecco DOC and DOCG Colli di Conegliano there has long been a lack of sharing and conflict between vine and wine producers and citizens, associations of environmental movements and with other associations in the territory. It was therefore conceived in 2017 by the corresponding author and a permanent table was then established in 2019 based on research and activities on Sustainability EME4.1C which considers in a harmonious chain all the material, immaterial, moral and spiritual factors related to all environmental, economic, social, existential, relational, ethical, technical and “MetaEthical” aspects of the Great Chain MetaEthical 4.1C of the Algorithm EcoMetaEthical 4.1C or AlgorMetaEthical4.1C of the Conegliano Campus 5.1C which also valorize the encyclicals Laudato Si and Fratelli tutti. This application was created thanks to the important contribution given by Don Andrea Forest, the Bishop’s Delegate, with the activation of the “Dialogue Table” and the “Sustainability Coordination 4.1C” of this Diocese and by Pr. Paolo Cescon of the Ca Foscari University of Venice and subsequently also by Pr. Paolo Sambo of the University of Padua.

Materials and methods. In the territory of Prosecco DOCG, Prosecco DOC and DOCG Vini dei Colli di Conegliano to overcome the lack of sharing and conflict between Stakeholders, these, the Stakeholders were invited to a dialogue table not by the world of science or by the local administrations but by the religious authority to arrive not at a compromise but at a new opinion shared between them. Subsequently, this opinion was submitted to the judgment of researchers indicated independently of the stakeholders reported above so that we could move, as we did, from a shared opinion among stakeholders to a scientifically shared opinion fundamental for planning the next coordinated activities between them. Activities aimed at increasing scientific knowledge, culture, general and applied training from childhood to university, information, as well as creating demonstration activities in the territory, communication, marketing on sustainability by applying the model of “Sustainability EcoMetaEthical 4.1C”.

Results. The activity carried out has already contributed and it appears that it will contribute even more in the future: 1. to increase the culture and universal basic and applied scientific knowledge, 2. to eliminate conflict between the various stakeholders, 3. to find in dialogue Sustainable EcoMetaEthical 5.1C-4.1C solutions, 4. to apply and have these Sustainable EcoMetaEthical 5.1C-4.1C solutions applied in relation to the planned next activities that concern the two sectors developed in these six years to which is added the continuation Ad Maiora 5.1C of the activities of the Conegliano Campus 5.1C planned and activated in 1996 which will receive a decisive boost and completion with regard to scientific activities, training from childhood to University, information, communication, marketing and the valorisation of the activities, productions and products of EME4.1C, 5, to avoid doing like other do, 6. to the reduction of bureaucracy, 7. to increase: 1. the preference for EME4.1C productions, 2. business profit, 3. collaborations between the bearers of knowledge, of MetaEthical 5.1C-4.1C material, immaterial, spiritual and moral interests considering that this activity is expanding elsewhere.