Terroir 2004 banner
IVES 9 IVES Conference Series 9 Effects of soil and climate on wine style in the Breede River Valley of South Africa: Sauvignon blanc and Cabernet-Sauvignon

Effects of soil and climate on wine style in the Breede River Valley of South Africa: Sauvignon blanc and Cabernet-Sauvignon

Abstract

[English version]

Les effets du sol et du climat sur le style de vin ont été évalués pour des vignes irriguées à deux endroits différents de la vallée de la Breede, en Afrique du Sud. L’un des 2 endroits est cependant plus froid que l’autre, principalement en raison de températures nocturnes plus basses. Des mesures ont été faites pour le Sauvignon blanc et le Cabernet Sauvignon, aux deux localités. Deux formations pédologiques ont été identifiées au sein des deux vignobles de Sauvignon Blanc. A l’endroit le plus frais, le premier sol est sableux (4% d’argile), tandis que le second est plus argileux (21% argile). Par conséquent, la capacité de rétention d’eau (sur la profondeur racinaire) est de 62 mm/m pour le premier et de 157 mm/m pour le second. Une situation comparable existe au sein du vignoble de Sauvignon blanc à l’endroit plus chaud, avec une capacité de rétention d’eau allant de 60 mm/m pour le premier sol à 112 mm/m pour le deuxiéme. Une seule formation pédologique (terreau sableux contenant 18% d’argile) a été identifiée pour le Cabernet Sauvignon à l’endroit le plus frais. Par contre, à l’endroit le plus chaud, on trouve deux sols divergeants. Le premier contient seulement 2% d’argile, alors que le second en contient 37%, aboutissant à des structures de sol largement divergeantes.
Pour le Sauvignon blanc, l’intensité des arômes était plus élevée dans les vins de la localité la plus fraîche que celle dans les vins de la localité de la plus chaude, et ceci indépendemment du sol. A l’endroit le plus frais, les différents sols ont aussi produit des styles differents. En général, les vins issus du sol sableux sont dits “typiques” par comparaison à ceux issus du sol plus argileux. A l’endroit plus chaud, le style du Sauvignon blanc n’a pas été affecté par le sol. Dans le cas du Cabernet Sauvignon, l’intensité arômatique était comparable entre les vins issus de l’endroit plus frais et les vins issus du sol argileux de l’endroit le plus chaud. Cependant, les styles de vins étaient largement divergents, ainsi les vins de l’endroit le plus frais révélaient un caractère herbacé prononcé, alors que les baies dominaient pour le vin de la localité la plus chaude. A l’endroit le plus chaud, le style du Cabernet Sauvignon était aussi affecté par le sol, avec des notes de baies et une intensité arômatique plus faible pour les vins issus du sol sableux.
Les résultats indiquent que le style de vin de la vallée de la Breede n’est pas seulement affecté par le climat, mais aussi par la formation pédologique. L’effet du sol peut-être dimimuée où l’irrigation est scientifiquement programmée, mais pas entièrement éliminée.

The effects of soil and climate on wine style were evaluated for irrigated vineyards at two different localities in the Breede River Valley of South Africa. One locality was cooler than the other, largely on account of lower night temperatures. Measurements were done for Sauvignon blanc and Cabernet Sauvignon, at both localities. Two contrasting soil forms were identified within both Sauvignon blanc vineyards. At the cooler locality the first soil was sandy (4% clay), while the second was more clayey (21% clay). This resulted in a water holding capacity of 62 mm/m for the first, in comparison to 157 mm/m for the second. A comparable situation existed within the Sauvignon blanc vineyard at the warmer locality, with water holding capacity ranging from 66 mm/m to 112 mm/m for the two soils. Only one soil form (sandy loam, containing 18% clay) was identified for Cabernet Sauvignon at the cooler locality. At the warmer locality, however, two divergent soil forms occurred within the Cabernet Sauvignon vineyard. The first contained only 2% clay, in comparison to 37% for the second, resulting in widely divergent soil structures.
For Sauvignon blanc, aroma intensity was higher in wines from the cooler locality than in those from from the warmer locality, irrespective of soil form. At the cooler locality different soil forms also induced divergent styles. In general, wine from the sandy soil was regarded as more “typical”, in comparison to the one from the more clayey soil. At the warmer locality the style of Sauvignon blanc was not affected by soil form. In the case of Cabernet Sauvignon, aroma intensity was comparable for the wine from the cooler locality and the one from the clayey soil at the warmer locality. However, styles were widely divergent, with wine from the cooler locality exhibiting a pronounced grass character, in comparison to a berry character for the one from the warmer locality. At the warmer locality the style of Cabernet Sauvignon was also affected by soil form, with berry character and aroma intensity being lower in wine from the sandy soil.
Results indicated that the style of wines from Breede River Valley is not only affected by climate, but also by soil form. The effect of soil form can be diminished where irrigation is scientifically scheduled, but not entirely eliminated.

DOI:

Publication date: January 12, 2022

Issue: Terroir 2004

Type: Article

Authors

W.J. Conradie (1) and V. Bonnardot (2)

1) ARC Infruitec-Nietvoorbij, Private Bag X5026, 7599 Stellenbosch, Republic of South Africa
2) ARC Institute for Soil, Climate and Water, Private Bag X5026, 7599 Stellenbosch, Republic of South Africa

Contact the author

Keywords

Soil, climate, Breede River Valley, wine style, Sauvignon blanc, Cabernet-Sauvignon

Tags

IVES Conference Series | Terroir 2004

Citation

Related articles…

Impact of geographical location on the phenolic profile of minority varieties grown in Spain. II: red grapevines

Because terroir and cultivar are drivers of wine quality, is essential to investigate theirs effects on polyphenolic profile before promoting the implantation of a red minority variety in a specific area. This work, included in MINORVIN project, focuses in the polyphenolic profile of 7 red grapevines minority varieties of Vitis vinifera L. (Morate, Sanguina, Santafe, Terriza Tinta Jeromo Tortozona Tinta) and Tempranillo) from six typical viticulture Spanish areas: Aragón (A1), Cataluña (A2), Castilla la Mancha (A3), Castilla –León (A4), Madrid (A5) and Navarra (A6) of 2020 season. Polyphenolic substances were extracted from grapes. 35 compounds were identified and quantified (mg subtance/kg fresh berry) by HPLC and grouped in anthocyanins (ANT) flavanols (FLAVA), flavonols (FLAVO), hydroxycinnamic (AH), benzoic (BA) acids and stilbenes (ST). Antioxidant activity (AA, mmol TE /g fresh berry) was determined by DPPH method. The results were submitted to a two-way ANOVA to investigate the influence of variety, area and their interaction for each polyphenolic family and cluster analysis was used to construct hierarchical dendrograms, searching the natural groupings among the samples. Sanguina (A3) had the most of total polyphenols while Tempranillo (A5) those of ANT. Sanguina (A2) and (A3) reached the highest values of FLAVO, FLAVA and AA. These two last samples had also the maximum of AA. The effect cultivar and area were significant for all polyphenolic families analyzed. A high variability due to variety (>50%) was observed in FLAVA and the maximum value of variability due to growing area was detected in AA (86.41%), ANT and FLAVO (51%); the interaction variety*zone was significant only for ANT, FLAVO, EST and AA. Finally, dendrograms presented five cluster: i) Sanguina (A2); ii) Sanguina (A3); iii) Tempranillo (A5); iv) Tempranillo (A3); Terriza (A3,A5), Morate (A5,A6); v) Santafé (A1,A6); Tortozona tinta (A1,A3,A6); Tinta Jeromo (A3,A4).

Heatwaves and grapevine yield in the Douro region, crop model simulations

Heatwaves or extreme heat events can be particularly harmful to agriculture. Grapevines grown in the Douro winemaking region are particularly exposed to this threat, due to the specificities of the already warm and dry climatic conditions. Furthermore, climate change simulations point to an increase in the frequency of occurrence of these extreme heat events, therefore posing a major challenge to winegrowers in the Mediterranean type climates. The current study focuses on the application of the STICS crop model to assess the potential impacts of heatwaves in grapevine yields over the Douro valley winemaking region. For this purpose, STICS was applied to grapevines using high-resolution weather, soil and terrain datasets over the Douro. To assess the impact of heatwaves, the weather dataset (1989-2005) was artificially modified, generating periods with anomalously high temperatures (+5 ºC), at certain onset dates and with specific durations (from 5 to 9 days). The model was run with this modified weather dataset and results were compared to the original unmodified runs. The results show that heatwaves can have a very strong impact on grapevine yields, strongly depending on the onset dates and duration of the heatwaves. The highest negative impacts may result in a decrease in the yield by up to -35% in some regions. Despite some uncertainties inherent to the current modelling assessment, the present study highlights the negative impacts of heatwaves on viticultural yields in the Douro region, which is critical information for stakeholders within the winemaking sector for planning suitable adaptation measures.

Making sense of available information for climate change adaptation and building resilience into wine production systems across the world

Effects of climate change on viticulture systems and winemaking processes are being felt across the world. The IPCC 6thAssessment Report concluded widespread and rapid changes have occurred, the scale of recent changes being unprecedented over many centuries to many thousands of years. These changes will continue under all emission scenarios considered, including increases in frequency and intensity of hot extremes, heatwaves, heavy precipitation and droughts. Wine companies need tools and models allowing to peer into the future and identify the moment for intervention and measures for mitigation and/or avoidance. Previously, we presented conceptual guidelines for a 5-stage framework for defining adaptation strategies for wine businesses. That framework allows for direct comparison of different solutions to mitigate perceived climate change risks. Recent global climatic evolution and multiple reports of severe events since then (smoke taint, heatwave and droughts, frost, hail and floods, rising sea levels) imply urgency in providing effective tools to tackle the multiple perceived risks. A coordinated drive towards a higher level of resilience is therefore required. Recent publications such as the Australian Wine Future Climate Atlas and results from projects such as H2020 MED-GOLD inform on expected climate change impacts to the wine sector, foreseeing the climate to expect at regional and vineyard scale in coming decades. We present examples of practical application of the Climate Change Adaptation Framework (CCAF) to impacts affecting wine production in two wine regions: Barossa (Australia) and Douro (Portugal). We demonstrate feasibility of the framework for climate adaptation from available data and tools to estimate historical climate-induced profitability loss, to project it in the future and to identify critical moments when disruptions may occur if timely measures are not implemented. Finally, we discuss adaptation measures and respective timeframes for successful mitigation of disruptive risk while enhancing resilience of wine systems.

Rootstock regulation of scion phenotypes: the relationship between rootstock parentage and petiole mineral concentration

Grapevine is grown as a graft since the end of the 19th century. Rootstocks not only provide tolerance to Phylloxera but also ensure the supply of water and mineral nutrients to the scion. Rootstocks are an important mean of adaptation to environmental conditions, because the scion controls the typical features of the grapes and wine. However, among the large diversity of rootstocks worldwide, few of them are commercially used in the vineyard. The aim of this study was to investigate the extent to which rootstocks modify the mineral composition of the petioles of the scion. Vitis vinifera cvs. Cabernet-Sauvignon, Pinot noir, Syrah and Ugni blanc were grafted onto 55 different rootstock genotypes and planted in a vineyard as three replicates of 5 vines. Petioles were collected in the cluster zone with 6 replicates per combination. Petiolar concentrations of 13 mineral elements (N, P, K, S, Mg, Ca, Na, B, Zn, Mn, Fe, Cu, Al) at veraison were determined. Scion, rootstock and the interaction explained the same proportion of the phenotypic variance for most mineral elements. Rootstock genotype showed a significant influence on the petiole mineral element composition. Rootstock effect explained from 7 % for Cu to 25 % for S of the variance. The difference of rootstock conferred mineral status is discussed in relation to vigor and fertility. Rootstocks were also genotyped with 23 microsatellite markers. Data were analysed according to genetic groups in order to determine whether the petiole mineral composition could be related to the genetic parentage of the rootstock. Thanks to a highly powerful design, it is the first time that such a large panel of rootstocks grafted with 4 scions has been studied. These results give the opportunity to better characterize the rootstocks and to enlarge the diversity used in the vineyard.

Comparison of imputation methods in long and varied phenological series. Application to the Conegliano dataset, including observations from 1964 over 400 grape varieties

A large varietal collection including over 1700 varieties was maintained in Conegliano, ITA, since the 1950s. Phenological data on a subset of 400 grape varieties including wine grapes, table grapes, and raisins were acquired at bud break, flowering, veraison, and ripening since 1964. Despite the efforts in maintaining and acquiring data over such an extensive collection, the data set has varying degrees of missing cases depending on the variety and the year. This is ubiquitous in phenology datasets with significant size and length. In this work, we evaluated four state-of-the-art methods to estimate missing values in this phenological series: k-Nearest Neighbour (kNN), Multivariate Imputation by Chained Equations (mice), MissForest, and Bidirectional Recurrent Imputation for Time Series (BRITS). For each phenological stage, we evaluated the performance of the methods in two ways. 1) On the full dataset, we randomly hold-out 10% of the true values for use as a test set and repeated the process 1000 times (Monte Carlo cross-validation). 2) On a reduced and almost complete subset of varieties, we varied the percentage of missing values from 10% to 70% by random deletion. In all cases, we evaluated the performance on the original values using normalized root mean squared error. For the full dataset we also obtained performance statistics by variety and by year. MissForest provided average errors of 17% (3 days) at budbreak, 14% (4 days) at flowering, 14.5% (7 days) at veraison, and 17% (3 days) at maturity. We completed the imputations of the Conegliano dataset, one of the world’s most extensive and varied phenological time series and a steppingstone for future climate change studies in grapes. The dataset is now ready for further analysis, and a rigorous evaluation of imputation errors is included.