Terroir 2004 banner
IVES 9 IVES Conference Series 9 Effects of soil and climate on wine style in the Breede River Valley of South Africa: Sauvignon blanc and Cabernet-Sauvignon

Effects of soil and climate on wine style in the Breede River Valley of South Africa: Sauvignon blanc and Cabernet-Sauvignon

Abstract

[English version]

Les effets du sol et du climat sur le style de vin ont été évalués pour des vignes irriguées à deux endroits différents de la vallée de la Breede, en Afrique du Sud. L’un des 2 endroits est cependant plus froid que l’autre, principalement en raison de températures nocturnes plus basses. Des mesures ont été faites pour le Sauvignon blanc et le Cabernet Sauvignon, aux deux localités. Deux formations pédologiques ont été identifiées au sein des deux vignobles de Sauvignon Blanc. A l’endroit le plus frais, le premier sol est sableux (4% d’argile), tandis que le second est plus argileux (21% argile). Par conséquent, la capacité de rétention d’eau (sur la profondeur racinaire) est de 62 mm/m pour le premier et de 157 mm/m pour le second. Une situation comparable existe au sein du vignoble de Sauvignon blanc à l’endroit plus chaud, avec une capacité de rétention d’eau allant de 60 mm/m pour le premier sol à 112 mm/m pour le deuxiéme. Une seule formation pédologique (terreau sableux contenant 18% d’argile) a été identifiée pour le Cabernet Sauvignon à l’endroit le plus frais. Par contre, à l’endroit le plus chaud, on trouve deux sols divergeants. Le premier contient seulement 2% d’argile, alors que le second en contient 37%, aboutissant à des structures de sol largement divergeantes.
Pour le Sauvignon blanc, l’intensité des arômes était plus élevée dans les vins de la localité la plus fraîche que celle dans les vins de la localité de la plus chaude, et ceci indépendemment du sol. A l’endroit le plus frais, les différents sols ont aussi produit des styles differents. En général, les vins issus du sol sableux sont dits “typiques” par comparaison à ceux issus du sol plus argileux. A l’endroit plus chaud, le style du Sauvignon blanc n’a pas été affecté par le sol. Dans le cas du Cabernet Sauvignon, l’intensité arômatique était comparable entre les vins issus de l’endroit plus frais et les vins issus du sol argileux de l’endroit le plus chaud. Cependant, les styles de vins étaient largement divergents, ainsi les vins de l’endroit le plus frais révélaient un caractère herbacé prononcé, alors que les baies dominaient pour le vin de la localité la plus chaude. A l’endroit le plus chaud, le style du Cabernet Sauvignon était aussi affecté par le sol, avec des notes de baies et une intensité arômatique plus faible pour les vins issus du sol sableux.
Les résultats indiquent que le style de vin de la vallée de la Breede n’est pas seulement affecté par le climat, mais aussi par la formation pédologique. L’effet du sol peut-être dimimuée où l’irrigation est scientifiquement programmée, mais pas entièrement éliminée.

The effects of soil and climate on wine style were evaluated for irrigated vineyards at two different localities in the Breede River Valley of South Africa. One locality was cooler than the other, largely on account of lower night temperatures. Measurements were done for Sauvignon blanc and Cabernet Sauvignon, at both localities. Two contrasting soil forms were identified within both Sauvignon blanc vineyards. At the cooler locality the first soil was sandy (4% clay), while the second was more clayey (21% clay). This resulted in a water holding capacity of 62 mm/m for the first, in comparison to 157 mm/m for the second. A comparable situation existed within the Sauvignon blanc vineyard at the warmer locality, with water holding capacity ranging from 66 mm/m to 112 mm/m for the two soils. Only one soil form (sandy loam, containing 18% clay) was identified for Cabernet Sauvignon at the cooler locality. At the warmer locality, however, two divergent soil forms occurred within the Cabernet Sauvignon vineyard. The first contained only 2% clay, in comparison to 37% for the second, resulting in widely divergent soil structures.
For Sauvignon blanc, aroma intensity was higher in wines from the cooler locality than in those from from the warmer locality, irrespective of soil form. At the cooler locality different soil forms also induced divergent styles. In general, wine from the sandy soil was regarded as more “typical”, in comparison to the one from the more clayey soil. At the warmer locality the style of Sauvignon blanc was not affected by soil form. In the case of Cabernet Sauvignon, aroma intensity was comparable for the wine from the cooler locality and the one from the clayey soil at the warmer locality. However, styles were widely divergent, with wine from the cooler locality exhibiting a pronounced grass character, in comparison to a berry character for the one from the warmer locality. At the warmer locality the style of Cabernet Sauvignon was also affected by soil form, with berry character and aroma intensity being lower in wine from the sandy soil.
Results indicated that the style of wines from Breede River Valley is not only affected by climate, but also by soil form. The effect of soil form can be diminished where irrigation is scientifically scheduled, but not entirely eliminated.

DOI:

Publication date: January 12, 2022

Issue: Terroir 2004

Type: Article

Authors

W.J. Conradie (1) and V. Bonnardot (2)

1) ARC Infruitec-Nietvoorbij, Private Bag X5026, 7599 Stellenbosch, Republic of South Africa
2) ARC Institute for Soil, Climate and Water, Private Bag X5026, 7599 Stellenbosch, Republic of South Africa

Contact the author

Keywords

Soil, climate, Breede River Valley, wine style, Sauvignon blanc, Cabernet-Sauvignon

Tags

IVES Conference Series | Terroir 2004

Citation

Related articles…

Impact of changes in pruning practices on vine growth and yield

A gradual decline in vineyards has been observed over the past twenty years worldwide. This might be explained by the climate change, practices change or the increase of dieback diseases. To increase the longevity of vines, we studied the impact of different pruning strategies in four adult and four young vineyards located in France and Spain. In France, vineyards were planted with Cabernet franc on 3309C while Spanish trials were planted with Tempranillo grafted on 110R. Vegetative expression, yield, quality of berries and wood vessels conductivity were measured. The distribution of vegetative expression, yield and berry composition between primary and secondary vegetation were quantified. Finally, tomography was used to evaluate the implication of the treatments on sap flows.
First results show that i) the respectful pruning leads to an increase of 30 to 50% more secondary shoots than the aggressive pruning in France and between 15 and 20% in Spain, ii) there is no major effect on the yield over the first two years following the implementation of the new pruning practices, although the proportion of clusters from suckers is higher on the respectful pruning method. On young vines, the development of the trunk according to a respectful pruning leads to a loss of harvest 2 years after planting. This is due to the removal, on the future trunk, of the green suckers which carrying bunches. This operation carried out in spring rather than during winter pruning, would promote a better leaf / fruit balance when the plant comes into production, and could lead to better hydraulic conduction in the vessels of the trunk. Maintaining these trials for several years will provide more robust data to assess the impact of these practices on the vines over the long term.

Phenological characterization of a wide range of Vitis Vinifera varieties

In order to study the impact of climate change on Bordeaux grape varieties and to assess the adaptation capacities of candidates to the grape varieties of this wine region to the new climatic conditions, an experimental block design composed of 52 grape varieties was set up in 2009 at the INRAE Bordeaux Aquitaine center. Among the many parameters studied, the three main phenological stages of the vine (budburst, flowering and veraison) have been closely monitored since 2012. Observations for each year, stage and variety were carried out on four independent replicates. Precocity indices have been calculated from the data obtained over the 2012-2021 period (Barbeau et al. 1998). This work allowed to group the phenological behaviour of the grapevine varieties, not only based on the timing of the subsequent developmental stages, but also on the overall precocity of the cycle and the total length of the cycle between budburst and veraison. Results regarding the variability observed among the different grape varieties for these phenological stages are presented as heat maps.

How can historical cultivars mitigate the effects of climate change?

IFV, INRAe and the national network “Partenaires de la Sélection Vigne” representing 37 organizations from the different wine regions, have been working increasingly closely over the last 2 decades towards the preservation of the French varietal patrimony. There are approximately 600 patrimonial varieties according to INRAe and SupAgro Montpellier experts, including ancient cultivars (400) and intravarietal crossbreeds obtained since the 19th century. In the context of a drastic reduction in such varieties from the mid 1980’s in favor of mainstream varieties, it was essential to carry out an inventory of old vines and vineyards. INRAe Vassal collection plays a key role here as it holds the largest diversity available, along with a rich bibliography and herbariums, offering us the opportunity to document and double check the identity of a cultivar, consolidating the expertise of ampelographers. The work is carried out in several stages, from verifying the existence of a variety in a small region, through to rehabilitation. During this session, the authors present the process that leads to the official registration of a variety. After this, IFV selection center takes over to initiate the process of selection and propagation. A specific focus within regions such as the Alps, Champagne and the South-West will provide details of the full procedure. Bia, Bouysselet, Chardonnay rose, Mecle and the aptly named Tardif, are some of the cultivars that have followed this procedure. Furthermore, a recent regulation established by INAO on “varieties of interest for adaptation purposes” might boost uptake by growers. Since 2006, 36 historical cultivars have been registered. Most of these have been neglected in the past due to late maturity, lack of sugar and high titratable acidity at harvest time. Such characteristics are today considered as positive qualities, not only in mitigation of the effects of climate change, but also as an opportunity for restoring diversity…

Adaptation to soil and climate through the choice of plant material

Choosing the rootstock, the scion variety and the training system best suited to the local soil and climate are the key elements for an economically sustainable production of wine. The choice of the rootstock/scion variety best adapted to the characteristics of the soil is essential but, by changing climatic conditions, ongoing climate change disrupts the fine-tuned local equilibrium. Higher temperatures induce shifts in developmental stages, with on the one hand increasing fears of spring frost damages and, on the other hand, ripening during the warmest periods in summer. Expected higher water demand and longer and more frequent drought events are also major concerns. The genetic control of the phenotypes, by genomic information but also by the epigenetic control of gene expression, offers a lot of opportunities for adapting the plant material to the future. For complex traits, genomic selection is also a promising method for predicting phenotypes. However, ecophysiological modelling is necessary to better anticipate the phenotypes in unexplored climatic conditions Genetic approaches applied on parameters of ecophysiological models rather than raw observed data are more than ever the basis for finding, or building, the ideal varieties of the future.

Grapevine varietal diversity as mitigation tool for climate change: Agronomic and oenologic potential of 14 foreign varieties grown in Languedoc region (France)

Climate change effects in Languedoc include an expected rise in temperatures, increased evapotranspiration as well as more severe and frequent climatic hazards, such as frost, drought periods and heat waves. For winegrowers theses phenomena impact both yield and quality, resulting in more frequent unbalanced wines. Research on identified mitigation tools for vineyard management is necessary to improve resilience of grapevine agrosystems. Varietal assortment is one of them. This study focuses on agronomic and oenologic potential of 14 foreign varieties grown in Languedoc French region. Fourteen grapevine varieties were monitored during 2021 from June until harvest on eight different sites, some of which occurring on more than one site adding up to 21 different modalities: 7 white varieties Alvarinho B, Assyrtiko B (2), Malvasia Istriana B, Parellada B, Verdejo B, Verdelho B, Xarello B, and 7 black varieties Saperavi N (2), Touriga nacional N, Baga N, Aleatico N, Montepulciano N (2), Primitivo N (3), Calabrese N (3). Varietals were compared through the following parameters: phenology was assessed by using the information collected in the Database Network of French Vine Conservatories (INRAE-SupAgro-IFV, 2005-2015). The number of inflorescences for shoots from secondary buds and bourillons and suckers were observed to assess post-bud break frost tolerance potential. Grapevine water status was studied through stem water potential measurement, observation of foliage symptoms of drought, and 𝛿13C on must. Frequencies and intensities of downy mildew, powdery mildew, and black rot attacks were estimated before harvest on leaves and clusters and botrytis at harvest to assess disease susceptibilities. Berry composition was monitored from end of veraison until harvest. Yield and mean bunch weight were also calculated. Varieties were then ranked on a 1-4 scale for each parameter and compared through PCA. Forty two stations of the Mediterranean basin were compared by PCA with the Multicriteria Climatic Classification indicators in order to confront the collected information during 2021 campaign to the hypothesis that plants coming from dry and hot regions are genetically adapted to such climatic conditions.