Terroir 2004 banner
IVES 9 IVES Conference Series 9 The role of mechanization in zone/terroir expression

The role of mechanization in zone/terroir expression

Abstract

Vineyard mechanization will be addressed in this review paper primarily as related to pruning and harvesting since these operations typically require a great deal of the total yearly labour demand (Intrieri and Poni, 1998). However, to be able to define how mechanization interacts with “terroir”, a rigorous definition of the latter term is needed.
James Goode (www.wineanorak.com) states that “terroir” must be reserved solely to describe the physical environment in which the grapevine grows – that is the soil type, microclimate and slope of a defined area. However, we would rather prefer the following broader definition; “Terroir: the ecology of a wine. The total, inter-related environment wherein a grapevine is cultivated for the purpose of making wine. Key factors include, but are not limited to, cultivar type, soil, climate, vineyard location, planting density, training system, pruning philosophy & the cultural and social milieu wherein the whole enterprise takes place”. In fact, we think that also choices like vine spacing or training system define a “terroir”; if we imagine a high-density vineyard trained to goblet in the south of France to be pulled out and replanted at wider spacing with a strikingly different trellis, could we say that the wine coming from that vineyard is still the expression of the same “terroir”? We doubt it.
Once “terroir” has been generally defined, it has to be verified if the definition holds for both Old and New World. To simplify, it can be stated that Old World terroirists aim to make wines that express the “typicity” of the vineyard site by putting a major emphasis on soil effects; in the New World the “terroir” effect has been somewhat disregarded and it is still viewed, under a more pragmatic way, as a route to improved quality.
Here, another important question rises: are both Old and New World facing viticultural changes that will soon affect the relationship between “terroir” and mechanization? The answer is in the affirmative although these changes have different rationales. The increasing cost of hand labour, often associated with the difficulties of finding skilled workers (mostly for winter pruning), will indeed produce in the Old World an increased interest in mechanized grape production systems. It is a trend that will be hastened if this process is paralleled by lower wine prices on the market.
The New World is already highly mechanized (Australia is the appropriate example here). This high degree of mechanization is facilitated, among many factors, by vineyard size. It is known that some New World vineyards are hundreds of hectares in size, while some in the more traditional parts of Europe are fractions of a hectare. However, this also means that when very large vineyards are machine-harvested in Australia, different “terroirs” are likely blended and their individual winemaking potential is diluted or dispersed.
Given that wine quality is enhanced by fermenting homogeneous lots of fruits and that variation in batches of delivered grapes is mainly due to soil (Smart, 1996), several large companies in Australia are tackling soil mapping to spot zones of similar “Readily Available Water” or are considering precision viticulture (Morris, 2001). Using global positioning systems (GPS) in association with geographical information systems (GIS) makes it possible to divide vineyards into management grids, each of which is quantified and treated separately. Technology is already available (Robertson, 2000) to build sensors that record specific information from each vine in order to formulate maps for vigour, °Brix, phenols and so forth. Of course, this has an impact on mechanization since machineries are being modified to incorporate computerized monitoring devices and sensors. A pertinent example is GIS driven mechanical harvesters, which can adjust speed or slapper frequency according to the maturity gradient along a vine row. Quite paradoxically, it appears that the New World is moving quickly towards these techniques to fill the gap with the Old World in terms of “terroir” expression.
Mechanization clearly interacts with many of the key factors listed within the broader definition
of “terroir” (namely vineyard location, planting density and training system). Yet the meaning of “terroir” nowadays is still being associated with the general concept of “recognizable” grape quality. Therefore, the interaction between vineyard mechanization and “terroir” can probably be analyzed from two basic viewpoints:
A) How does the concept of full vineyard mechanization fit with maintenance of high quality requirements? This is a crucial issue. Indeed, still widespread in the Old World viticultural countries, such as Italy, it the “rule of thumb” whereby a fully mechanized vineyard cannot give top quality and that only the patient hand labour can actually achieve the “gold standards”;
B) Is mechanization a useful tool to reach maximum vineyard efficiency? A reasonable definition of vineyard efficiency is reaching the highest yield at the “desired” or “salable” quality at the lowest production costs.
The B statement broadens the area of interaction between mechanization and “terroir”. Here a suitable example is provided in Figure 1, showing the fractional distribution (year 2003) of exported Italian wine as a function of price per litre (Pedron, 2004). The narrow pyramid shows that only 2.9% of the total value is sold at prices higher than €6/l, whereas more than 65 % of the value goes to prices lower than €3/l. Therefore, restricting the term “terroir” to the top price would basically eliminate the need to investigate the interaction between “terroir” and “mechanization” since those bottles are quite likely coming from prestigious sites where labour cost is not, at least not yet, a priority. Clearly, even the lowest price rate can be representative of a “terroir” if the definition given at the beginning of this introduction holds.

DOI:

Publication date: January 12, 2022

Issue: Terroir 2004

Type: Article

Authors

S. Poni (1), C. Intrieri (2)

(1) Istituto di Frutti-viticoltura, Università Cattolica del Sacro Cuore di Piacenza, Italy
(2) Dipartimento di Colture Arboree, Università degli Studi di Bologna, Italy

Tags

IVES Conference Series | Terroir 2004

Citation

Related articles…

Genotypic variability in root architectural traits and putative implications for water uptake in grafted grapevine

Root system architecture (RSA) is important for soil exploration and edaphic resources acquisition by the plant, and thus contributes largely to its productivity and adaptation to environmental stresses, particularly soil water deficit. In grafted grapevine, while the degree of drought tolerance induced by the rootstock has been well documented in the vineyard, information about the underlying physiological processes, particularly at the root level, is scarce, due to the inherent difficulties in observing large root systems in situ. The objectives of this study were to determine genetic differences in the root architectural traits and their relationships to water uptake in two Vitis rootstocks genotypes (RGM, 140Ru) differing in their adaptation to drought. Young rootstocks grafted upon the Riesling variety were transplanted into cylindrical tubes and in 2D rhizotrons under two conditions, well watered and moderate water stress. Root traits were analyzed by digital imaging and the amount of transpired water was measured gravimetrically twice a week. Root phenotyping after 30 days reveal substantial variation in RSA traits between genotypes despite similar total root mass; the drought-tolerant 140Ru showed higher root length density in the deep layer, while the drought-sensitive RGM was characterised by shallow-angled root system development with more basal roots and a larger proportion of fine roots in the upper half of the tube. Water deficit affected canopy size and shoot mass to a greater extent than root development and architectural-related traits for both 140Ru and RGM, suggesting vertical distribution of roots was controlled by genotype rather than plasticity to soil water regime. The deeper root system of 140Ru as compared to RGM correlated with greater daily water uptake and sustained stomata opening under water-limited conditions but had little effect on above-ground growth. Our results highlight that grapevine rootstocks have constitutively distinct RSA phenotypes and that, in the context of climate change, those that develop an extensive root network at depth may provide a desirable advantage to the plant in coping with reduced water resources.

Exploring resilience and competitiveness of wine estates in Languedoc-Roussillon in the recent past: a multi-level perspective

The Languedoc-Roussillon wineries are facing a decline in wine yields particularly PGI yields due to many factors. Climate change is just ones, but is expected to increase in the future. There is also structurally a large heterogeneity of yield profiles among terroirs, varieties and strategies. This work investigates the link between yield, competitiveness and resilience to explore how resilient winegrowers have been in the recent past. To this end two approaches have been combined; (i) an accountancy database analysis at estate scale and (ii) municipality level competitiveness analysis. A new resilience indicator that characterizes the capacity of an estate to absorb yield variation is also defined. The FADN database between 2000 and 2018 of ex-Languedoc-Roussillon (France) and other data are used to analyse the current situation and the past evolution of competitiveness and resilience by type of estate (type of farm: PGI and/or PDO & type of commercialization: bulk and/or bottles). The net margin, which defines competitiveness, is not correlated to yield for all types but depends on the type of commercialization and the level of specialisation. The resilience indicator shows that the net margin of estates specialized in PGI is particularly sensitive to yield declines. We also show that price evolutions seem to compensate the effect of yield losses for the majority of types. Municipality scale analysis shows the links between local pedoclimate, yield, commercialization strategies and price. Overlapping a PDO with a PGI does not always increase a municipality’s PGI competitiveness. It is difficult to make links between causes and effects due to the complexity of the wine production system. Production diversification may be a solution. Resorting to the two level of analysis helps resolving the data gap that is necessary to explore the links between yield and economic performance of the wine estates in the long term.

Effect of partial net shading on the temperature and radiation in the grapevine canopy, consequences on the grape quality of cv. Gros Manseng in PDO Pacherenc-du-vic-Bilh

As elsewhere, southwestern France vineyards face more recurrent summer heat waves these last years. Among the possibilities of adaptation to this climate changing parameter, the use of net shading is a technique that allow for limiting canopy exposure to radiations. In this trial, we tested net shading installed on one face of the canopy, on a north-south row-oriented plot of cv. Gros Manseng trained on VSP system in the PDO Pacherenc-du-Vic-Bilh. The purpose was to characterize the effects on the ambient canopy temperatures and radiations during the season and to observe the consequences on the composition of grapes and wines. Two sorts of net were used with two levels of obstruction (50% and 75%) of the photosynthesis active radiation (PAR). They have been installed on the west side of the canopy and compared to a netless control. Temperature and PAR sensors registered hourly data during the season. On specific summer day (hot and sunny) manual measurements took also place on bunches (temperature) and in different spots of the canopy (PAR). The results showed that, on clear days, the radiation is lowered by the shade nets respecting the supplier criteria. The effects on the ambient canopy temperature were inconstant on this plot when we observed the data from the global period of shading between fruit set and harvest. However, during hot days (>30°C), the temperature in the canopy was reduced during afternoon and the temperature of the bunch surface was reduced as well comparing to the control. A decrease of the maturity parameters of the berries, sugar and acidity, was also observed. Concerning the wine aromatic potential, no differences clearly appeared.

The impact of leaf canopy management on eco-physiology, wood chemical properties and microbial communities in root, trunk and cordon of Riesling grapevines (Vitis vinifera L.)

In the last decades, climate change required already adaptation of vineyard management. Increase in temperature and unexpected weather events cause changes in all phenological stages requiring new management tools. For example, defoliation can be a useful tool to reduce the sugar content in the berries creating differences in the wine profiles. In a ten-year field experiment using Riesling (Vitis vinifera L, planted 1986, Geisenheim, Germany), various mechanical defoliation strategies and different intensities were trialed until 2016 before the vineyard was uprooted. Wood was sampled from the plant compartments root, trunk, cordon and shoot for analyses of physicochemical properties (e.g. lignin and element content, pH, diameter), nonstructural carbohydrates and the microbial communities. The aim of the study was to investigate the influence of reduced canopy leaf area on the sink-source allocation into different compartments and potential changes of the fungal and prokaryotic wood-inhabiting community using a metabarcoding approach. Severe summer pruning (SSP) of the canopy and mechanical defoliation (MDC) above the bunch zone decreased the leaf area by 50% compared to control (C). SSP reduced the photosynthetic capacity, which resulted in an altered source-sink allocation and carbohydrate storage. With lower leaf area, less carbohydrates are allocated. This for example resulted in a decreased trunk diameter. Further, it affected the composition of the grapevine wood microbiota. SSP and MDC management changed significantly the prokaryotic community composition in wood of the root samples, but had no effect in other compartments. In general, this study found strong compartment and less management effects of the microbial community composition and associated physicochemical properties. The highest microbial diversities were identified in the wood of the trunk, and several species were recorded the first time in grapevine.

Sustainable fertilisation of the vineyard in Galicia (Spain)

Excessive fertilization of the vineyard leads to low quality grapes, increased costs and a negative impact on the environment. In order to establish an integrated management system aimed at a sustainable fertilization of the vineyards, nutritional reference levels were established. For this purpose, 30 representative vineyards of the Albariño variety were studied, in which soil and petiole analyses were carried out for two years and grape yield and quality at harvest were measured. In both years of study, soil pH, calcium, sodium and cation exchange capacity were positively correlated with calcium content and negatively correlated with manganese in grapes. Irrigated vineyards had higher levels of aluminium in soil and lower levels of calcium in petiole. Climatic conditions were very different in the years of the study. The year 2019 was colder than usual, in 2020 there was a marked water stress with high summer temperatures. This resulted in medium-high acidity in grapes in 2019 and low acidity in 2020, with sugar levels being similar both years. A very marked decrease in must amino nitrogen was observed in 2020, with ammonia nitrogen remaining stable. The correlation of acidity and sugar values in grapes with soil and petiole analysis data made it possible to establish reference levels for the nutritional diagnosis of the Albariño variety in this region. Based on these results, an easy-to-use TIC application is currently being created for grapegrowers, aimed at improving the sustainability of the vineyard through reasoned fertilization. This study has now been extended to other Galician vine varieties.