terclim by ICS banner
IVES 9 IVES Conference Series 9 OIV 9 OIV 2024 9 Orals - Economy and law 9 “Q & A” of the european commission for labeling and desalcoholization for wines: european wine “soft-law”?

“Q & A” of the european commission for labeling and desalcoholization for wines: european wine “soft-law”?

Abstract

Recently, the European Commission seems to have inaugurated a new mechanism for regulating the wine sector. Through two communications, articulated in the form of “Questions & Answers”, concerning the new rules for labeling (24.11.2023) and dealcoholization of wine (15.01.2024), the Commission is not simply “explaining” the new rules but, in an approach close to the theory of “Circulaire Normative” established in comparative law, chooses among different interpretations and even adds Praeter Legem constraints. The paper examines the content of these texts, a priori of low normativity, and considers that they reveal a new regulatory model which may seem prima facie adapted to the specificities of the European wine sector but which, in reality, challenges cardinal principles of European law, such as legal certainty, institutional balance, transparency, and even subsidiarity. Hence the need to limit this practice. Finally, the paper questions the articulation of such a soft-law practice with the resolutions of the OIV.

Les « questions & réponses » de la commission européenne en matière d’étiquetage et de désalcoolisation des vins : du « soft-law » vitivinicole européen ?

Récemment, la Commission Européenne semble avoir inauguré un mécanisme inédit de régulation du secteur vitivinicole. Par deux communications, articulées sous forme de « Questions & Réponses », concernant les nouvelles règles d’étiquetage (24.11.2023) et de désalcoolisation du vin (15.01.2024), la Commission ne se contente pas « d’expliquer » les nouvelles règles mais, dans une démarche qui rappelle la théorie de la « Circulaire Normative » connue en droit comparé, choisit parmi différentes interprétations et même ajoute des contraintes Praeter Legem. Le papier examine le contenu de ces textes, a priori de faible normativité, et considère que nous sommes devant un nouveau modèle de régulation qui semble Prima Facie adapté aux spécificités du secteur vitivinicole européen mais qui, en réalité, remet en question des principes cardinaux du droit européen, tels que la sécurité juridique, l’équilibre institutionnel, la transparence et même la subsidiarité. D’où le besoin de circonscrire cette pratique. Enfin, le papier s’interroge sur l’articulation d’une telle pratique de soft-law avec les résolutions de l’OIV.

Le “domande & risposte” della commissione europea su etichettatura e dealcolazione dei vini: della “soft-law” vitivinicolo europeo?
Recentemente, la Commissione Europea sembra aver inaugurato un nuovo meccanismo di regolamentazione del settore vitivinicolo. Attraverso due comunicazioni, articolate sotto forma di “Domande & Risposte”, riguardanti le nuove regole di etichettatura (24.11.2023) e dealcolazione del vino (15.01.2024), la Commissione non si accontenta di “spiegare” le nuove norme ma, in un approccio che ricorda la teoria della “Circolare Normativa” nota in diritto comparato, sceglie tra diverse interpretazioni e addirittura aggiunge vincoli Praeter Legem. Il contributo esamina il contenuto di questi testi, a priori poco normativi, e ritiene che siamo di fronte a un nuovo modello normativo che sembra Prima Facie adattato alle specificità del settore vitivinicolo europeo ma che, in realtà, chiama in causa i principi cardine del diritto europeo, quali la certezza del diritto, l’equilibrio istituzionale, la trasparenza e perfino la sussidiarietà. Da qui la necessità di limitare questa pratica. Infine, il documento mette in discussione l’articolazione di tale pratica di soft-law con le risoluzioni dell’OIV.
Publication date: November 18, 2024

Issue: OIV 2024

Type: Article

Authors

Théodore Georgopoulos¹

¹ Université de Reims, 32 Rue de Betheny, Reims, France

Contact the author*

Tags

IVES Conference Series | OIV | OIV 2024

Citation

Related articles…

Reconfiguring wine prescription : from traditional critics to digital social networks

The integration of digital social networks (DSN) has profoundly transformed communication practices within the wine industry, reorganizing the dynamics of prescription and marketing.

Big data analysis of pesticides from the vine to the winery

Of biocontrol products and resistant grape varieties, synthetic pesticides are still widely used to control fungal diseases and protect vines from potential damage caused by pests. The use of pesticides is strictly regulated, and their use can sometimes lead to transfer from the grapes to the must and then into the wine. The study of pesticide residues in grapes and wines is commonly carried out by wine producers in order, among other things, to optimize treatment routes, check that products comply with regulations, and ultimately guarantee the food safety of the wine.

Evolution of the metabolic profile of grapes in a context of climate change

In the current context of global climate change, anticipating the evolution of the oenological potential of emblematic grape varieties of regions such as Burgundy and Champagne is a guarantee of the sustainability of a sector which has considerable economic weight. however, if various models of climate change cast doubt on the sustainability of these grape varieties in these regions, appellation decrees, as well as consumer expectations, do not allow or consider the use of alternative grape varieties. In addition, control/compensation methods such as irrigation are also not permitted.

Ecodesign tools and approaches in viticulture for professionals and learners, contributions of the Vitarbae project

The agro-ecological transition in winegrowing can benefit from the environmental assessment of practices to inform producers’ technical choices. life cycle assessment (lca) evaluates the environmental impact of a product over its entire life cycle. this paper takes a look at the tools available for the detailed assessment and eco-design of winegrowing practices, their uses and developments in the vitarbae research project (2023-2026). this project aims to establish and equip support and training courses for the agroecological transition in viticulture and fruit arboriculture.

Carbon footprint in Austrian viticulture – Evaluation of the main polluters and possible solutions in entire the production chain

The sustainability certification ‘nachhaltig austria’ (www.sustainableaustria.com) has been offered to austrian wineries in an online version for 10 years and over 25% of the austrian wine-growing area is now certified. Since the 2022 harvest, ‘nachhaltig austria’ has automatically calculated the carbon footprint for each winery, per hectare of vineyard, per litre of bulk wine and per 0.75-litre bottle (poelz, w. And rosner, f.g. 2023). In last year’s publications and numerous presentations at national and international level, topics such as refilling glass bottles, lightweight glass bottles, renewable energy, … Etc.